Skip to main

Where Great Pizza Meets a Great Story

How Dave’s Pizza Garage Began

How Dave’s Pizza Garage Began

In 2001, I moved from Buffalo, NY, to Tallahassee, FL, to attend Florida State University and pursue a career in elementary education. While I loved my new home, I couldn’t shake the feeling that something was missing—specifically, the pizza I grew up with. To recreate that familiar flavor, I started baking pies in my kitchen. What began as a way to share a little bit of home with family and friends soon turned into something much bigger.

From Homemade Pies to a Local Favorite

From Homemade Pies to a Local Favorite
Word spread quickly. Friends told friends about the pizzas I was making, calling it “the BEST pizza they ever tasted.” Before long, I set up an email ordering system and started delivering pizzas around Tallahassee. It wasn’t long before my wife said, “Go BIG or go home.” Translation: “I’m tired of doing all these dishes—open a restaurant!” With her encouragement, we took the leap.

Opening the Garage Doors

Opening the Garage Doors
In April 2013, Dave’s Pizza Garage opened its first location on North Monroe in midtown Tallahassee. From day one, our goal was simple: to make pizza and wings for people who want the best and know the difference. Over the years, we built great relationships with the community and met incredible people who supported us every step of the way.

Why You Should Visit

Why You Should Visit
Dave’s Pizza Garage is more than a restaurant—it’s a place where families and friends can gather, share a meal, and create memories. If you’re in Tallahassee and looking for a locally owned gem with incredible pizza, wings, and more, come see us. We’re here to make sure you leave with a smile and a reason to come back. Stop by and make Dave’s Pizza Garage your go-to spot for amazing food and great company. We can’t wait to see you!