The Best Pizza in Tallahassee - Dave's Pizza Garage

Dave’s Pizza Garage Tallahassee

serves the best pizza and wings but also offers a wide array of other family favorites that you can enjoy at our family friendly restaurant or for takeaway. We offer gluten free and vegetarian choices plus kid’s meal for the young ones.

beef on weck

A buffalo favorite. Thin-sliced roast beef served on a salty kimmelweck roll. Dipped in Au Jus with a side of horseradish

wings with DAVE s Signature sauce

buffalo style wings done right

pizza logs

The original pizza logs from Buffalo, NY.
It’s pizza rolled up into a tasty fried treat!

The Brookie

Dave’s Homemade Chewy chocolate chip cookie baked inside of a delicious chocolatey brownie!

poutine

Golden fries and gooey melted mozzarella cheese topped with homemade brown gravy

BUFFALO-STYLE PIZZA is a thing!
IT S not NY or Chicago. It s BUFFALO!

Try A little Cup & Char pepperoni TODAY!

Five Speed Cheese Calzone

Ricotta, mozzarella, provolone, cheddar & feta cheeses

Dave s Cookies

Dave’s original recipe. Homemade chewy chocolate chip cookie made from scratch

ORDER ONLINE

MORE MENU

authentic
Buffalo, NY style
pizza & wings

Dave’s Pizza Garage in Tallahassee will give you and your family a taste of a unique style of pizza and other menu items brought down from Buffalo, NY.

Enjoy our pizza with a crispy crust on the outside and a soft chewy inside covered with a slightly sweet sauce and whole milk mozzarella and tiny pepperonis that cup and char when baked. All ingredients are made fresh every day – the dough, the sauce & freshly shredded cheese. We only use the freshest vegetables as toppings and for our vegetarian options. The gluten-free crust is also available.

Don’t forget to try our homemade secret recipe chewy chocolate chip cookies.